All About Andrew County Mutual Insurance

Family Home

Our History

On December 21st, 1889, Farmer’s Mutual Fire, Lighting and Windstorm Insurance Company was organized. Its office was located in Bolckow, MO, the home of the secretary. In 1962, the company was moved to 422 Court Street on the south side of the square in Savannah, MO. In 1975 at the annual meeting, it was voted to rename the company Andrew County Mutual Insurance. The company is a 380 mutual insurance company and is owned by its policyholders and the company is run by nine Board of Directors.

Our Agents

Meet our Agents that are ready to serve you, or you can reach all of our office staff at 816 324-3151.


Terry Evans, Agent

Terry Evans

Terry Evans has lived in the Helena, Cosby community his whole life. After graduating Savannah High School in 1973 he began farming with his dad and still operates the farms today. In 1986 he was asked to be on the Andrew County weed Control board and still serves today. In 1988 Terry joined his dad in the auction business and today along with his wife Debbie operate Terry Evans Auction Service. In 2000 he became a director with Andrew County Mutual Insurance Company. He was asked to become an agent in 2001 and continues to be an agent/director today.

He can be contacted at Home
816-378-2010 or Cell 816-271-3794.

Read More

Ray Furst, Agent

Ray Furst

Ray is a 5th generation Andrew Countian with over 30 years of serving your insurance needs and always ready to answer  insurance questions or concerns.

Telephone: 816-261-6441

Read More

Randy Roberts, Agent

Randy Roberts

Randy enjoys working with people and meeting new people that a lot of times become new friends. He is also known for his sweet corn and pumpkins he supplies to the local stores.

Telephone: 816-387-6508

Read More

Jennifer Pflugradt, Agent

Jennifer Pflurgradt

After working in the office 3 years I decided I would like to be an agent because I love meeting people and am excited to be able to serve all of your insurance needs.  I live in Savannah with my husband Travis and have two kids who love the outdoors as much as we do. Give me a call today to review your insurance coverage and let me give you an auto quote today.

Telephone: 816-341-9713

Read More

Felisha DeSpain, Manager

Felisha DeSpain is the Office Manager for Andrew County Mutual Insurance Company who works with the policy holders to ensure they have the correct coverages they need and answer any questions they may have. Felisha has over 15 years or Customer Service experience as well as Office Management experience. Felisha serves as a Savannah Chamber of Commerce Board Member and she is also the Vice President of the Minnie Cline PTO. She is always ready to help our customers as well as folks looking to compare rates for their insurance. Giver her a call at the office today.

Read More

Contact Information

Andrew County Mutual Insurance Company 816-324-3151